13 Jul Sarasota Delights: Exciting First Date Restaurants in Sarasota, FL 

Author: Alex Raynes

Ah, the thrill of a first date! Sarasota, Florida, offers a plethora of delightful dining options that cater to singles over 45 seeking a memorable evening out. From romantic waterfront views to trendy eateries, this vibrant city has it all. In this blog, we will take you on a culinary adventure and share some of the best first-date dinner locations in Sarasota, guaranteed to impress and create a lasting impression.

1. Shore Diner:

Located in the heart of St. Armands Circle, Shore Diner is a fantastic choice for a first date. This casual yet chic spot offers a laid-back atmosphere, friendly service, and a delectable menu featuring coastal-inspired cuisine. From fresh seafood to mouthwatering steaks, the diverse menu caters to a range of tastes. Don’t miss the chance to savor their famous Key Lime Pie—it’s the perfect sweet ending to a delightful evening.

2. The Cottage:

If you’re looking for a charming and cozy ambiance, The Cottage is an excellent choice. Located in the Southside Village neighborhood, this intimate bungalow-turned-restaurant exudes romance. Their farm-to-table approach ensures fresh, locally sourced ingredients that elevate every dish. With a menu that celebrates both Southern and Mediterranean flavors, you and your date can indulge in dishes like crispy Brussels sprouts, shrimp and grits, and a delightful selection of craft cocktails.

3. Marina Jack II Dinner Cruise:

For a truly unique and unforgettable first-date experience, consider the Marina Jack II Dinner Cruise. Set sail on Sarasota Bay aboard a luxurious yacht while enjoying a delicious dinner. The panoramic views of the bay, the city’s skyline, and breathtaking sunsets provide a stunning backdrop for an evening of romance. Feast on a delectable buffet-style meal featuring a variety of dishes, including fresh seafood, prime rib, and mouthwatering desserts.

The 7 Lucky Steps That Lead To Successful Dating After Divorce

4. Selva Grill:

For those seeking an exotic and adventurous dining experience, Selva Grill is a must-visit. This vibrant Latin fusion restaurant in downtown Sarasota offers an eclectic menu that combines flavors from Peru, Argentina, and other Latin American countries. The stylish and lively ambiance sets the stage for a memorable evening. Be sure to try their ceviche, empanadas, and unique cocktails like the Pisco Sour or the Passionfruit Mojito.

5. Indigenous:

Nestled in the Towles Court Arts District, Indigenous is a gem for food lovers and art enthusiasts alike. This farm-to-table restaurant celebrates locally sourced ingredients and seasonal flavors, showcasing the best of Florida’s culinary offerings. The intimate setting, adorned with local artwork, creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. Treat your taste buds to creative dishes like Gulf shrimp and grits, braised short ribs, or their famous heirloom tomato salad.

5 Things You Can Do To Be More Romantic

6. Ophelia’s on the Bay:

For a romantic waterfront setting, Ophelia’s on the Bay is a perfect choice. Nestled along Little Sarasota Bay, this restaurant offers stunning views and a serene ambiance. The menu highlights fresh seafood, grilled steaks, and Mediterranean-inspired dishes. Start your evening with their famous Ophelia’s Crab Cakes and savor the flavors while enjoying the breathtaking sunset from their outdoor patio.

7. Element:

If you and your date appreciate contemporary cuisine with a twist, Element is the place to be. Located in downtown Sarasota, this trendy restaurant offers a sophisticated dining experience. The menu showcases innovative dishes crafted with local and sustainable ingredients. From their creative appetizers to their indulgent desserts, each plate is a work of art. Be sure to sample their handcrafted cocktails and explore the extensive wine list to complement your meal.

Sarasota is a haven for singles over 45 seeking a memorable first-date dinner. From casual coastal fare to elegant waterfront dining, this city offers a variety of delightful options to suit every taste and ambiance preference. Whether you choose the charm of The Cottage, the exotic flavors of Selva Grill, or the romantic setting of Ophelia’s on the Bay, these dining destinations are sure to set the stage for a fantastic evening filled with great conversation, delicious food, and the potential for a lasting connection. So, put on your best smile and embark on a culinary adventure in the enchanting city of Sarasota. Bon appétit!